Plant-based fish substitutes: exploring healthy alternatives

Many individuals choose to avoid eating fish for various reasons, including ethical, health, ecological, or religious concerns. However, some people still crave the taste and texture of fish dishes and recipes. Fortunately, there are several convincing substitutes available that not only replicate the taste but also offer additional health benefits. With the rise in plant-based foods and increased consumer awareness about the ecological impact of fishing, manufacturers are now offering a wide variety of fish alternatives. These alternatives include plant-based fish sticks, fishcakes, and even scampi and shrimp.

Table of Contents

Plant-Based Fish Substitutes

Brands use a variety of ingredients such as seaweed, tofu, and banana blossom to create these fish alternatives. They may also utilize artificial flavorings or natural foods to replicate a fish-like taste. Let's explore some popular fish substitutes and how they can be used to recreate favorite fish dishes.

Tofu Fish (‘Tofish’)

Tofu is an excellent substitute for fish due to its white color and ability to emulate the texture of fish. When used in place of fish, it is sometimes referred to as tofish. Battered tofish with chips (fries) is a popular vegan alternative to the classic fish and chips dish. To make battered tofish, simply wrap a nori (seaweed) sheet around a fish-sized piece of firm tofu and coat it in batter before frying. You can make the batter using cornstarch and seltzer water or beer. Serve with traditional or vegan tartar sauce for a delicious meal. Tofu is a good source of protein and calcium, making it an ideal choice for those following a plant-based diet.

Smoked Carrot Salmon

Carrots may seem like an unusual choice as a salmon substitute, but when marinated in flavorings, they make an excellent fish alternative. Smoked carrot salmon can be used to top bagels spread with vegan cream cheese or for sushi. To make smoked carrot salmon, slice four peeled carrots into long, thin strips using a peeler or mandolin. Steam the carrot slices for 5 minutes until tender. In a container, combine the carrot strips with chopped nori sheets, apple cider vinegar, smoked paprika, garlic powder, tamari, and a few drops of liquid smoke. Toss lightly to coat and refrigerate overnight to marinate. Before serving, lightly coat the strips in olive oil and liquid smoke. Use them to top bagels or in sushi.

Banana Blossom Fish

Banana blossom, a fleshy flower that grows on the banana plant, has recently become a popular fish alternative for those following a plant-based diet. Its neutral flavor makes it ideal for adding seaweed or other fish substitute flavorings. Additionally, banana blossom's chunky and flaky texture makes it an excellent substitute for battered cod or fish fillet. You can buy canned banana blossom to make fish recipes or enjoy it at vegan food outlets and restaurants.

Jackfruit Tuna

For those looking for a plant-based tuna substitute, jackfruit is an excellent option due to its similar flaky texture. Jackfruit is readily available in cans and can be easily separated with a fork before marinating or cooking. Flavor the jackfruit with nori or soy sauce to give it a fishy taste, and add vegan mayonnaise if desired to create a tuna mayonnaise sandwich filling or use it in tuna salads.

Other Fish Substitutes and Recipes

In addition to the options mentioned above, there are several other fish substitutes available:

  • Seitan Scampi, Prawns, and Shrimp: Seitan, a vital wheat gluten with a meaty texture, can be used to create plant-based alternatives for seafood. Add flavorings and liquid to the seitan powder, shape it into fish or seafood shapes, and cook it. You can also add a natural food coloring to emulate the color of prawns or shrimp.
  • Vegan Fish Sticks and Fillets: Manufacturers use wheat gluten, soy, or mycoprotein to make popular vegan fish fillets and fish sticks. You can make a homemade version using firm tofu flavored with nori sheets and lemon juice, coated in breadcrumbs.
  • Garbanzo Bean Fish-less Cakes: Mashed garbanzo beans mixed with mashed potato, parsley, nori, and scallions can be shaped into fish cakes. Coat them in panko breadcrumbs and bake them in the oven. Garbanzo beans are a good source of protein and fiber.
  • Mushroom Fish Pie: Mushrooms are an excellent fish substitute due to their protein-rich, meaty texture and rich flavor. Use oyster mushrooms, tofu, and vegetables in a white sauce for a delicious fish pie. Top it with creamy mashed potato and grated dairy-free cheese.
  • Teriyaki Chicken Sushi Rolls: Substitute fish for chicken in teriyaki chicken sushi rolls for a protein-packed and vitamin B12-rich alternative. If following a vegan or plant-based diet, substitute chicken with tofu, tempeh, or imitation chicken.

Fish-Like Flavorings

To replicate a fish-like flavor, several ingredients can be used in recipes:

  • Soy Sauce: Contains amino acids that provide an umami-like flavor, useful for fish recipes.
  • Liquid Aminos: Similar taste to soy sauce, providing an umami flavor.
  • Tamari: A gluten-free alternative to soy sauce.
  • Mushrooms: Mushrooms or mushroom sauce add a rich umami flavor to plant-based dishes.
  • Seaweed: Adds a fish-like flavor to dishes. Nori, wakame, kombu, and dulse are popular options. Seaweed is also a good source of iodine and contains minerals such as calcium and magnesium.

With the abundance of plant-based options available today, finding a substitute for smoked trout or any other type of fish is easier than ever. Whether you choose tofu, smoked carrot salmon, banana blossom, jackfruit, seitan, or other alternatives, you can recreate your favorite fish dishes and enjoy the taste and texture without compromising your dietary preferences or concerns. Experiment with different recipes and flavorings to discover your favorite smoked trout substitute and embark on a delicious and sustainable culinary journey.

If you want to know other articles similar to Plant-based fish substitutes: exploring healthy alternatives you can visit the Plant-based fish substitutes category.

Go up

We use our own and third-party cookies to prepare statistical information and show you personalized content and services through navigation analysis. Accept them or set your preferences. More Information